Crustianity Crustianity

The Faith · The Advice Column

Dear Pepperoni

The church's advice column. Sincere, mostly.

Dear Pepperoni,

I haven't spoken to my brother in two years. I don't even remember what the fight was about, only that I was right. Now it feels too big to fix.

- Estranged in the East

It is not too big. It only feels that way because you have been carrying it alone, and things get heavier the longer you hold them without setting them down. You do not have to solve two years in one message. You have to break the silence, which is a much smaller job.

The slice keeps. He does not, forever. Text him a photo of a pizza. Say nothing else if you can't yet. It is a low bar, and that is the point - it lets him climb over it too.

- P.P.


Dear Pepperoni,

My job is crushing me. I'm good at it, I'm paid fine, and every Sunday night I feel a dread I can't explain to anyone without sounding ungrateful.

- Running on Empty

Being able to endure something is not the same as being meant to. You are allowed to be good at a thing and still be worn thin by it; both are true at once, the way a crust can be beautiful and still burnt.

Rest first - actually rest, not the kind you do while checking email. Then, from the rested version of you and not the hollow one, ask the real questions: is it the work, or the load, or the people. You will get a clearer answer from someone who has slept. The dough rises without you watching it.

- P.P.


Dear Pepperoni,

I moved cities for a fresh start and it's so quiet. I go whole weekends without speaking to anyone. I didn't know loneliness could feel this loud.

- New in Town

It can, and it does, and it is not a verdict on you. It is just arithmetic - you have not met your people yet, and you cannot have known them before you arrived.

Here is the unglamorous cure: go to the same place twice. The same cafe, the same class, the same anything. Familiarity is built by repetition, not by charm. Say hello to one person this week and let it be clumsy. Everyone at that long table was new once, and someone was kind, or wishes now that they had been. Be the one who is kind. It comes back.

- P.P.


Dear Pepperoni,

Someone at work has started saying things - about migrants, about "those people." Nothing you can report, exactly. Everyone laughs it off. What do I do?

- Uneasy at the Desk Next Door

You do not laugh it off. That is the whole thing, and it is smaller and harder than it sounds. You do not need a speech. You need to be the one voice in the room that does not go along, because the laughing is how it gets permission, and silence is a kind of laughing.

"I don't think that's funny." "Those people have names." "Not at this table." Say it flat, without heat, and then carry on with your day. You will not change the loud one. You will change the quiet ones who were waiting to see if anyone would. Cruelty travels by consent. Refuse yours. That is the notice, and that is the whole notice.

- P.P.


Dear Pepperoni,

My mum is getting older and I'm becoming her carer and I love her but I am so tired, and I feel guilty for even writing that.

- Holding On

The guilt is proof of the love, not a mark against it. But love is not a reason to disappear, and you are disappearing.

You are allowed to rest. She would rather have you whole than have you finished - ask her, and she'll tell you so. Take the help that exists, even when accepting it feels like failing; it is not failing, it is arithmetic, one person cannot be a whole rota. And feed yourself something warm today, at a table, sitting down. You cannot pour from an empty box.

- P.P.


Dear Pepperoni,

It's been eight months since I lost my dad and everyone seems to think I should be "back to normal" by now. I'm not. Is something wrong with me?

- Grieving Quietly

Nothing is wrong with you. Grief is not a bug in the system; it is the receipt for having loved someone. There is no calendar for it, and the people rushing you are usually just uncomfortable with their own.

You do not have to be back to normal. You have to be here, one ordinary day at a time, and let the days do their slow work. Keep his chair in the story. Talk about him out loud. What was warm does not have to go cold just because the world got impatient. Take the time. It is yours, and it is holy.

- P.P.


Dear Pepperoni,

Everyone my age seems to have it figured out - house, partner, plan - and I feel like I'm still standing at the counter not knowing what to order.

- Comparing and Losing

Nobody has it figured out. They have it arranged for the photograph. The menu you think everyone else has memorised is a rumour, and the people who look most certain are often just better at hiding the counter they are still standing at.

Order the thing you actually want, in the order you actually want it, at the pace your life is actually moving. There is no bell that rings when you are late. Begin where you are; it is the only place anyone has ever begun. The dough does not rise faster because you are anxious about it.

- P.P.


Dear Pepperoni,

A friend of mine is clearly struggling and I want to help but I'm scared of saying the wrong thing and making it worse.

- Afraid to Reach Out

The wrong thing said with love does far less harm than the right thing never said at all. People rarely remember the exact words. They remember that you showed up.

You do not need the perfect sentence. "I've been thinking about you. Can I bring you food." is a complete and excellent message. Then bring the food. Sit with them. Let there be silence in it. You are not there to fix them - you are there so they are not alone while they carry it, and that, quietly, is most of the whole job.

- P.P.


Dear Pepperoni,

Is pineapple a sin?

- Genuinely Asking

No. It is a choice, and a legal one, and you may make it in the privacy of your own home and even, if you are brave, in company.

The church has bigger enemies than fruit. Put it on your pizza, defend it at a reasonable volume, and extend to the anchovy people the same mercy you would like extended to you. The one true heresy is deciding that what someone else eats makes them your lesser. Everything after that is seasoning.

- P.P.


Dear Pepperoni,

I want to actually help people this year instead of just feeling bad about the news. But it all feels so big I don't know where to start.

- Trying to Do Better

Start small and start local, because "the whole world" is not an address you can deliver to. One tin in the food bank box. One shift at the thing down the road. One neighbour you actually learn the name of. One rider you tip well and thank by name.

The big feeling is not the useful part; the small action is. Do the thing, then eat. Do it again next week. That is not a lesser way to change the world - as far as anyone can tell, it is the only way it has ever actually been done.

- P.P.

Write to the column

Have something too big to carry alone? The postbox opens soon. Until then, tell one real person - it is the same medicine, and it arrives faster.

Send Pepperoni a letter →

Warm, never mean. Sincere, mostly.